Page 1 of 6

Merry-Go-Round/Emitt Rhodes question

Posted: Wed May 04, 2005 5:53 pm
by David R. Modny
After seeing that Rev-Ola has a new, and much needed, Merry-Go-Round comp coming out this week...I have a question.

Has "Time Will Show The Wiser" ever appeared in true stereo? I have the Varese Rhodes comp - where it has the "45 version" (mono). The new MGR disc apparently has both the "45" & "album" version on it. Are they different mixes entirely or is the original album version just a stereo mix of the single? I don't own the debut MGR LP so I'm not sure how it existed there.

Posted: Wed May 04, 2005 7:31 pm
by Xenu
Yes, it has appeared in stereo. It was likely on the debut LP, and it's certainly on the not-that-hard-to-find-and-will-likely-get-easier-to-find-AND-it-sounds-great Japanese A&M CD. It's a wiiideee stereo mix of the single performance. Want I should MP3 it forya?

Posted: Wed May 04, 2005 7:42 pm
by David R. Modny
Xenu wrote:Yes, it has appeared in stereo. It was likely on the debut LP, and it's certainly on the not-that-hard-to-find-and-will-likely-get-easier-to-find-AND-it-sounds-great Japanese A&M CD. It's a wiiideee stereo mix of the single performance. Want I should MP3 it forya?



By all means...MP3! Ya' anywhere near those two Gene Clark/Byrds '70 mixes we talked about a few weeks back? If so, I'd love a listen.

I've been staying with a friend during these past few illness months. So the stray charity MP3 that floats my way is pretty much the basis of my listening these days!

If you're able...just up 'em to LP's server and email me the link dmodny@cox.net

TIA

Posted: Wed May 04, 2005 7:53 pm
by Xenu
Which Byrds '70s mixes? You missed my at-home window...I might have *some* of the stuff up here, but not all of it.

So I have two different CDRs of the ER material. One was on a twofer with Days of Future Passed, of all things, and another is on something I made called "The Complete ER Collection," which seems to be (more or less) exactly what Rev-Ola is putting out. Odd.

As with the exception of "Missing You," this has all been on CD before, I wonder whether they've done new mastering?

Anyway, MP3 is at:
http://www.lukpac.org/~handmade/mgr.mp3

(note I didn't even penalize you for asking the same question at sh.tv)

Posted: Wed May 04, 2005 8:05 pm
by David R. Modny
Xenu wrote:Which Byrds '70s mixes? You missed my at-home window...I might have *some* of the stuff up here, but not all of it.


"She's the Kind of Girl" & "One in a Hundred." No biggie, if not.

I think it might have been my evil troll twin who posted on that subject... come to think of it.


Follow-up: I just listened to the posted stereo mix. Pretty interesting, fidelity-wise, but I think I like the cohesiveness of the mono mix better - everything just gels together better for me. Still...this was quite cool. Kinda that "listening to the multi-tracks" experience!

Thanks again!

Posted: Thu May 05, 2005 12:22 am
by Xenu
Ahh, fuck. I totally forgot, sorry. I'll grab them next pass..:-(

Any other MP3s from the MGR set requested?

Posted: Thu May 05, 2005 3:06 pm
by David R. Modny
Xenu wrote:Ahh, fuck. I totally forgot, sorry. I'll grab them next pass..:-(

Any other MP3s from the MGR set requested?


Hell...anything. I'd be interested in hearing the sound quality of your sources. "Til the Day After," "Come Ride, Come Ride," "On Your Way Out" are some of my favorites.

Again...thanks for your generosity!

Posted: Thu May 05, 2005 7:56 pm
by Xenu
Should I just shoot you a CDR?

-D

Posted: Thu May 05, 2005 8:01 pm
by lukpac
So what CD did you take that from?

Posted: Thu May 05, 2005 9:44 pm
by Leppo
Yes, I'd like to know too. Thanks for posting Time Will Show The Wiser, David.

Do you plan to get Listen Listen: The Definitive Collection?

Posted: Fri May 06, 2005 4:10 am
by Xenu
I took it from a homebrew CDR of mine, which is in turn taken from "Listen Listen: The Best of Emitt Rhodes" (or whatever the heck the Varese comp is called), "You're a Very Lovely Woman/Live" (Japanese A&M disc) and "American Dreamer" (Japanese Universal disc).

I'd like to point out again that barring "Missing You," I'm pretty sure this has all been on CD before. ANd why "Time Will Show the Wiser" in its single mix? That's been on CD! What about the '45 mixen of "Live" and "You're a Very Lovely Woman?"

Posted: Fri May 06, 2005 7:57 am
by lukpac
Xenu wrote:ANd why "Time Will Show the Wiser" in its single mix?


I love that stereo mix, but as DRM pointed out, it is a bit bare without the drums.

Posted: Fri May 06, 2005 10:58 am
by David R. Modny
For me it goes beyond the drums. I think the balance between the vocals and the backing tracks gel better on the mono mix. The vocals sound a bit "naked" on the stereo mix - particularly on the final line.

Still cool to hear in stereo...

David - that CDR will be great. Here's my current address (i.e. don't use the old one).

591 Azalea Circle
Northfield, OH 44067

Thanks again!
Dave

Posted: Fri May 06, 2005 2:04 pm
by Xenu
lukpac wrote:
Xenu wrote:ANd why "Time Will Show the Wiser" in its single mix?


I love that stereo mix, but as DRM pointed out, it is a bit bare without the drums.


Well, yes. What I'm saying is that the single mix has been available before, whereas there're a few single mixes that we haven't seen on CD yet (and I've always been curious as to what "You're a Very Lovely Woman" sounds like in its single incarnation).

Posted: Fri May 06, 2005 2:06 pm
by lukpac
Maybe they aren't that different?